Home · Blog · Operations and automation

Reviews on Airbnb, Booking.com and Stayz: what Australian guests actually mark you down for

Guests mark you down for a dirty changeover, a door code that fails and a fee they did not expect. Airbnb, Booking.com and Stayz publish reviews separately. Ask once, after checkout. Do not pay for a star. Reply with the fact and the fix, then stop.

Try ReceptionGO free for 30 days — no card needed. →

A 4.9 and a 4.6 feel similar until you read the last ten reviews. The marks Australian guests move are rarely “the view was average”. They are the shower, the late code, the cleaning fee that was not in the first price, and a rule about the pool that appeared on a sign in the bathroom. The platforms are just where that lands.

Three sites, one stay

Airbnb’s review is the one hosts obsess over, and it is blind for a window after checkout so neither side writes for the audience of the other. Booking.com’s guest reviews are a hotel habit — scores for cleanliness, location, value — and a holiday apartment is marked on the same form as a motel. Stayz reviews are where the Australian family who booked a week speaks, often at more length, often about whether the house matched the photos of the beds. A brilliant Airbnb score does not reprint itself onto Stayz. If Stayz is where the house actually sells, that is the score to watch. How the fees differ, which is a separate reason a guest feels tricked, is in fees.

Google is the fourth page, and it outlives a channel. A guest who had a fight about a bond will write it where search can see the property name. Claiming and answering that profile is Google and repeat guests.

Earn the score before you ask for it

The clean is the score. A changeover checklist, dry linen and a pool gate that is shut are worth more than a template message. That hour is changeovers. The arrival is the other score: a code that works, a light, the car park you described. That is online check-in. Rules they accepted on the way — occupancy, noise, the bond amount — mean the review cannot honestly start with “we were never told”. The bond itself should be boring: bonds and cancellations.

Then ask, once. The day after checkout. Not three times, and not with a coupon for five stars. The ACCC’s line on reviews is that they have to be genuine. A bribed star is a bigger problem than a four.

The reply

Write it as if the next guest is the audience, because they are. “Sorry the oven was not what you needed — it has been replaced” is a reply. A timeline of who said what in the OTA chat is not. If you were wrong, say so in the first line. If you were not, correct the one factual point and describe the rule as it was shown at booking. Do not name the guest’s children, their argument, or the dollar amount of a bond you kept, beyond what a stranger needs.

A string of reviews about the same item — parking, hot water, “smaller than the photos” — is not a reply problem. It is a listing problem or a house problem. Fix it before the January guests, who will write the reviews that sit at the top through autumn. Peak weeks produce more reviews because they produce more stays: the summer peak. A capped Byron or Sydney calendar means each of those reviews represents a scarce night. You cannot dilute a bad one with volume you are not allowed to sell. See Sydney if that is the constraint.

From our own practiceThe reviews that still sting are the ones where the guest was right and we already knew. The hot water, the missing teaspoon set, the direction that only makes sense if you have been there. We put those into the check-in message. The public reply is the smaller job.

Frequently asked questions

Which site’s review matters most?

The one your next guest is reading. A family booking a beach house on Stayz may never see your Airbnb score. A European guest on Booking.com may never see Stayz. Treat all three as live, and do not abandon the channel with the weaker score — fix the thing the score is describing. Google reviews sit beside them for anyone who searches the property name. That page is the Google guide.

Should I ask for a review?

Yes, once, after they have left, while the stay is still true. A message that says “if you were happy, a review helps; if something was wrong, tell me first” is fair. A discount for a five-star review is not, and the ACCC has views on reviews that are not genuine. Do not do it.

How do I reply to a bad one?

One paragraph. Thank them, state the fact you can stand behind, say what you changed, stop. Do not mention the bond dispute in detail, do not diagnose the guest, and do not copy the reply onto the other two sites unless the same guest reviewed there. Future guests read the reply to decide whether you are safe to deal with.

A guest is threatening a bad review unless I refund. What now?

That is leverage, not feedback. Refund what your policy and the evidence say you should refund — a real shortfall in the clean, a broken code — and do not refund a demand that is only a threat. Write down what you offered. If the review arrives and it is false, use that platform’s reporting process, not a novel in the comments.

Try it free

30 days, no commitment and no card. Setup takes minutes, and we help you personally with the first steps.

Start free

Sources

  1. Airbnb — reviews
  2. Booking.com Partner Hub — guest reviews
  3. ACCC — online reviews

Rules last checked on 22 October 2026.